Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Jane Austen's Skeletal Society

What I like about Emma is the shamelessness with which the characters go about openly adhering to the roles of the social classes. The best example of this is when Emma is angry that Mr. Elton would flatter himself by thinking that he were in a similar class. She mentions also that he does not have the mind to keep up with her, but what angers her most is the fact that he is lower than her on the social totem pole, but he attempts her courtship anyway. Furthermore, Mr. Elton isn't trying to erase social boundaries with his attempt at courtship, but rather he is appealing to his own perceived notion of acceptability. Both characters have this idea of social hierarchy that they feel no guilt or shame in invoking. Even Mr. Knightley, the most respectable character in the story understands the importance of class. Nowhere does anybody think it is at all unfair that people are judged on this scale.
I think this is interesting because now the idea of evaluating people by social class is a really terrible notion. Somewhere along the line people became disgusted, at least in principle, with relegating people to their fortune or social grace. But it still happens obviously, from the unspoken hierarchy that exists in every high school to the adult world where men compete for women's affections with expensive cars and well paying jobs. Nothing has changed, except people's willingness to discuss it.
I think a lot of this has to do with the idea of individualism. We want to be evaluated based on what we have to offer as people, rather than as figures of wealth and fortune. We want to be able to determine how we feel about people by the way they are. In Emma, individualism is a secondary point next to class. I've noticed A) how boring the conversations are, I believe Mr. Knightley spends an entire meal talking about farming. Farming! and B) how much effort is spent on civility and order. I love the idea of these gentlemen saying things like "If it were admissible to contradict a lady..." but it all stands as skeletal, as the constructed shell that allows for smooth order between people. There is more than one scene where Emma says things that contradict how she feels, in order to achieve some maintenance of order. But what I think is most interesting is that even though this is a modern book, there is not really lamentation about this lack of individuality. It certainly exists, and Emma's discussion of wit and mind certainly draw attention to it, but it is not nearly as important as social order.
So now, even though class still exists, individualism has become too important to openly sacrifice. We attempt individuality at all costs, and use social class as a back up for when we fail.

No comments: