Let's face it, this guy is one of the most awful characters ever conceived of in fiction. No Dickens villian could be as transparent or contemptible as Papa Grandet--the guy is pure evil, and if Balzac is saying that this is what people are like than I'm hitching to forested Sierra Leone to return to my roots with the savages.
The reasons for why this guy is so contemptible are obvious, but what stands out to me is the preface of the novel, in which grad school hero mentions several times that Balzac was capable of and did love his characters. Preliminary things I think should be pointed out: 1) the only flushed character is Grandet, I know next to nothing about Eugenie, 2) Balzac wasn't a writer, like so many of our modernist authors he was a guy, specifically a lawyer with some observations about the human condition that he wanted down on paper, 3) because he was a lawyer, the scenes in which fiscal law are discussed are painstakingly specific, and 4) this novel is indictment of human nature.
Interestingly, there are a lot of themes in Eugenie that only receive brief mention. There is the idea of religion, how it is dead in the hearts of men but how it really isn't, there are questions about Eugenie's life that don't get answered because Eugenie is not a strong enough character. The only thing that is painfully obvious is Grandet's unwholesome obsession with gold: he stares at gold for hours at a time! He's grasping for the Priest's crucifix! and the apparent observation that he isn't any different than anyone else, he's just more successful.
So I wonder if Balzac is saying that this is how people are, or about how rich people are, or if we can equate this obsession with money with an obsession of materialism, or some sort of God is Dead standpoint. But the overall message of the novel is quite depressing. I quote "How horrible is man's condition! He does not own one happiness whose source does not lie in ignorance of some kind." I'm reminded of the scene in which this quote occurs; Grandet's friends are over and it's apparent that nobody concerned has the slightest bit of affection for anyone else there. It's nauseating. And throughout the book we get Cruchot reminding Grandet of how close they are and Grandet doing the same to Cruchot, and I'm not inclined to believe either of them.
Again, Balzac was a lawyer, an observationist, not a writer, while the themes exist, they don't develop like they would in better novels. There isn't the inherent subtlety necessary to persuade me that Balzac was doing anything other than pointing out why people suck. Grandet doesn't redeem himself. I'm glad the bastard's dead. And I bet balzac is sort of glad he's dead.
Tuesday, November 27, 2007
Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Jane Austen's Skeletal Society
What I like about Emma is the shamelessness with which the characters go about openly adhering to the roles of the social classes. The best example of this is when Emma is angry that Mr. Elton would flatter himself by thinking that he were in a similar class. She mentions also that he does not have the mind to keep up with her, but what angers her most is the fact that he is lower than her on the social totem pole, but he attempts her courtship anyway. Furthermore, Mr. Elton isn't trying to erase social boundaries with his attempt at courtship, but rather he is appealing to his own perceived notion of acceptability. Both characters have this idea of social hierarchy that they feel no guilt or shame in invoking. Even Mr. Knightley, the most respectable character in the story understands the importance of class. Nowhere does anybody think it is at all unfair that people are judged on this scale.
I think this is interesting because now the idea of evaluating people by social class is a really terrible notion. Somewhere along the line people became disgusted, at least in principle, with relegating people to their fortune or social grace. But it still happens obviously, from the unspoken hierarchy that exists in every high school to the adult world where men compete for women's affections with expensive cars and well paying jobs. Nothing has changed, except people's willingness to discuss it.
I think a lot of this has to do with the idea of individualism. We want to be evaluated based on what we have to offer as people, rather than as figures of wealth and fortune. We want to be able to determine how we feel about people by the way they are. In Emma, individualism is a secondary point next to class. I've noticed A) how boring the conversations are, I believe Mr. Knightley spends an entire meal talking about farming. Farming! and B) how much effort is spent on civility and order. I love the idea of these gentlemen saying things like "If it were admissible to contradict a lady..." but it all stands as skeletal, as the constructed shell that allows for smooth order between people. There is more than one scene where Emma says things that contradict how she feels, in order to achieve some maintenance of order. But what I think is most interesting is that even though this is a modern book, there is not really lamentation about this lack of individuality. It certainly exists, and Emma's discussion of wit and mind certainly draw attention to it, but it is not nearly as important as social order.
So now, even though class still exists, individualism has become too important to openly sacrifice. We attempt individuality at all costs, and use social class as a back up for when we fail.
I think this is interesting because now the idea of evaluating people by social class is a really terrible notion. Somewhere along the line people became disgusted, at least in principle, with relegating people to their fortune or social grace. But it still happens obviously, from the unspoken hierarchy that exists in every high school to the adult world where men compete for women's affections with expensive cars and well paying jobs. Nothing has changed, except people's willingness to discuss it.
I think a lot of this has to do with the idea of individualism. We want to be evaluated based on what we have to offer as people, rather than as figures of wealth and fortune. We want to be able to determine how we feel about people by the way they are. In Emma, individualism is a secondary point next to class. I've noticed A) how boring the conversations are, I believe Mr. Knightley spends an entire meal talking about farming. Farming! and B) how much effort is spent on civility and order. I love the idea of these gentlemen saying things like "If it were admissible to contradict a lady..." but it all stands as skeletal, as the constructed shell that allows for smooth order between people. There is more than one scene where Emma says things that contradict how she feels, in order to achieve some maintenance of order. But what I think is most interesting is that even though this is a modern book, there is not really lamentation about this lack of individuality. It certainly exists, and Emma's discussion of wit and mind certainly draw attention to it, but it is not nearly as important as social order.
So now, even though class still exists, individualism has become too important to openly sacrifice. We attempt individuality at all costs, and use social class as a back up for when we fail.
Wednesday, October 3, 2007
More on Werther
Over the past two classes, similar forms of the same complaint against the protagonists of Werther and Adolphe have come up: that these people are bad people because they're selfish and completely inconsiderate, to the point of being sociopaths, of anybody else.
Really, in both cases it has been because of disarmingly honest idea that each of them have had: Werther because he believes Lotte should belong to her because of how badly he wants her, and Adolphe because he doesn't seem to mind much when Ellenore kicks it. Both of these scream selfish because they value the self over a kind of general societal benevolence that says we should all be good and reasonably altruistic people.
But it seems to me that this kind of solipsistic selfishness is the natural conclusion of modernism. Look at Rousseau, his monad is the man who can take care of himself completely without outside help or society. Kant's Enlightenment means being able to fill societal roles while still maintaining an independence from them. Werther is a man who lives within himself, who emotes the way he wants to and meets people on his own terms. In fact, he finds it impossible to meet anyone else on their terms, and is subsequently ostracised from the high society he enters when he begins work with the diplomat.
All of these make the case that the independent self is the thing that is to be valued the highest, so why waste time dealing with the sorrows and woes of others. Why bother trying to keep societal order if you're trying to live free. Wouldn't anything else be counter-productive? I mean, freedom comes at the expense of obligatory behavior, which is why Rousseau's monad didn't do it, and it's why Werther and Adolphe don't. Whether or not you think it's a good thing, the fact is being completely free means not ever doing things you don't want to do, no matter how much social pressure there is on you to do them. Meaning, if you don't feel bad when your woman dies, then don't. And maybe that makes you a sociopath, but it makes you free as well. And isn't that what modernism is supposed to be about?
Really, in both cases it has been because of disarmingly honest idea that each of them have had: Werther because he believes Lotte should belong to her because of how badly he wants her, and Adolphe because he doesn't seem to mind much when Ellenore kicks it. Both of these scream selfish because they value the self over a kind of general societal benevolence that says we should all be good and reasonably altruistic people.
But it seems to me that this kind of solipsistic selfishness is the natural conclusion of modernism. Look at Rousseau, his monad is the man who can take care of himself completely without outside help or society. Kant's Enlightenment means being able to fill societal roles while still maintaining an independence from them. Werther is a man who lives within himself, who emotes the way he wants to and meets people on his own terms. In fact, he finds it impossible to meet anyone else on their terms, and is subsequently ostracised from the high society he enters when he begins work with the diplomat.
All of these make the case that the independent self is the thing that is to be valued the highest, so why waste time dealing with the sorrows and woes of others. Why bother trying to keep societal order if you're trying to live free. Wouldn't anything else be counter-productive? I mean, freedom comes at the expense of obligatory behavior, which is why Rousseau's monad didn't do it, and it's why Werther and Adolphe don't. Whether or not you think it's a good thing, the fact is being completely free means not ever doing things you don't want to do, no matter how much social pressure there is on you to do them. Meaning, if you don't feel bad when your woman dies, then don't. And maybe that makes you a sociopath, but it makes you free as well. And isn't that what modernism is supposed to be about?
Tuesday, September 25, 2007
Werther, why are you so sad?
Werther, baby, cheer up, she's just a girl, there are plenty of other fish in the sea, and don't you know that you're the modern man, man? You're the real deal, introspective, curious, you burn to be alive, and you don't know how to be one of "those" people, those stuffy, class-oriented snobs with their good jobs and their status and their lack of happiness. The whole world goes by like clockwork and you stand in a field under a tree and say "no!" and you say that man is a victim of passion and he should be and then you go ahead and be one and even though it destroys you it's ok because you're doing what everyone wishes they could do, I mean you're alive baby! You're alive and your thriving. And whatever affliction may come your way accept that as much as it will hurt, and it will hurt, and you won't be able to tell yourself that it will someday stop because you're too beautiful to understand that-you're a Roman Candle baby-you'll get past it and move on to bigger and better things. And if there is no other Lotte, if you never find another, then know that you loved, you felt it in all it's wretched glory, and that's all you can do.
And thank you, for showing me that the Modern Man still exists. Are we still in a modern age: yes.
And thank you, for showing me that the Modern Man still exists. Are we still in a modern age: yes.
Tuesday, September 18, 2007
Jean-Jacques Rousseau meets Ayn Rand
I spent the summer reading The Fountainhead and trying to understand why my dad, who's a devout Catholic, liked it enough to recommend it to me. Apparently it's because it's well written - which it isn't - but I think that maybe it's because at this point in his life, when he's made too many decisions to reverse any of them, he sometimes likes to imagine a life that at some point in his life he kind of wanted. As a smart, affluent college kid who can afford not to make any decisions about anything ever, I'm holding judgement as to whether or not Ayn Rand, or Rousseau, actually had their shit together.
But I realize that Ayn Rand was saying the same thing that Rousseau did, and so was Hunter Thompson, or Charlie Parker, or any of these people who spent their entire lives trying to live outside the parameters of social acceptability. I think it's an idea that everyone has at some point, and I think most people end up forgetting about it or rejecting it because it doesn't seem possible, or it isn't possible, or the sacrifices you have to make to do it are things like leaving your children to fend for themselves, to ignore other people, to be rude when you feel like it, all things that Rousseau decided the savage man did without thought or regret.
Rousseau writes like there's nothing we can do to change our situation, that we've lost and we're going to be slaves forever. My personal favorite quote: "...and this feeling must utter the eulogy of your first ancestors, the indictment of your contemporaries, and the terror of those who have the misfortune to live after you." He's talking about us! What are we going to do?!
Ayn Rand writes about how giving yourself up to the times, heralding defeat, admitting it's hopeless is not justification, that we apologize if you are too weak to drag yourself up and pit yourself up against society, but we care nothing for you, are uninterested in the wretched life you will make for yourself, because if you were any kind of man - and I do say man because ms. Rand is so contemptful of women - you'd have disregarded the obstacles like they were cancers, and you'd have turned yourself into something. People called Ayn Rand selfish. She agreed.
I wonder if it's easier to acknowledge the futility of living by yourself inside society like Rousseau did and resign yourself to the tyranny and slavery that, let's be honest, we don't ever actually see, or to spend your entire life trying to find it. And I wonder if it is possible to find it, or whether it's possible for us affluent, smart college kids to find it, but not for the up-and-coming Drudge Report-reading New York Yuppies we'll undoubtedly become. I'd say probably. And again I'm left wondering why my father would want to read the kind of book that lambasts the kind of live he has. But I notice that he's never recommended A Discourse on inequality to me, or for that matter anything by Rousseau. Maybe even he, a 53 year old lobbyist with subscriptions to two Washington Insider magazines and a rolodex full of clients, isn't ready to lose hope quite yet. Maybe he's right. That would be nice, I think.
But I realize that Ayn Rand was saying the same thing that Rousseau did, and so was Hunter Thompson, or Charlie Parker, or any of these people who spent their entire lives trying to live outside the parameters of social acceptability. I think it's an idea that everyone has at some point, and I think most people end up forgetting about it or rejecting it because it doesn't seem possible, or it isn't possible, or the sacrifices you have to make to do it are things like leaving your children to fend for themselves, to ignore other people, to be rude when you feel like it, all things that Rousseau decided the savage man did without thought or regret.
Rousseau writes like there's nothing we can do to change our situation, that we've lost and we're going to be slaves forever. My personal favorite quote: "...and this feeling must utter the eulogy of your first ancestors, the indictment of your contemporaries, and the terror of those who have the misfortune to live after you." He's talking about us! What are we going to do?!
Ayn Rand writes about how giving yourself up to the times, heralding defeat, admitting it's hopeless is not justification, that we apologize if you are too weak to drag yourself up and pit yourself up against society, but we care nothing for you, are uninterested in the wretched life you will make for yourself, because if you were any kind of man - and I do say man because ms. Rand is so contemptful of women - you'd have disregarded the obstacles like they were cancers, and you'd have turned yourself into something. People called Ayn Rand selfish. She agreed.
I wonder if it's easier to acknowledge the futility of living by yourself inside society like Rousseau did and resign yourself to the tyranny and slavery that, let's be honest, we don't ever actually see, or to spend your entire life trying to find it. And I wonder if it is possible to find it, or whether it's possible for us affluent, smart college kids to find it, but not for the up-and-coming Drudge Report-reading New York Yuppies we'll undoubtedly become. I'd say probably. And again I'm left wondering why my father would want to read the kind of book that lambasts the kind of live he has. But I notice that he's never recommended A Discourse on inequality to me, or for that matter anything by Rousseau. Maybe even he, a 53 year old lobbyist with subscriptions to two Washington Insider magazines and a rolodex full of clients, isn't ready to lose hope quite yet. Maybe he's right. That would be nice, I think.
Tuesday, September 11, 2007
Declaration of the Rights of Man
This was the document that got referenced a lot while the constitution got written, right? I don't remember.
At any rate, it might as well be, it certainly reads like a prototype of the Bill of Rights. I thought it was interesting that only a few of the rights (speech, liberty, property, whatever) addressed the inherent rights that men would demand from inside themselves, and the rest were about authority's relationship to the rights of men. I thought modernism had more to do with self-exploration than internal relationships. What occurred to me while I read the assigned packet, and especially Edmund Burke's piece and Wordsworth's poem, was that introspection and self exploration had erased a lot of the reverence and awed happiness that existed before. David Hume deciding that there was no reason for cause and effect must have been unfathomable to a bunch of British farmers used to worshipping their queen and fasting on Fridays.
But as far as the Declaration itself goes, it all sounds relatively fair, if not entirely applicable. It's an interesting juxtaposition to Rousseau, who's been busy making the case that society is responsible for the weakening and corrupting of man. Looking at the two, I assume that the writers of each felt they were right. So what I wonder is, is modernity the attempt to improve the quality of man's life? Is it simply when people started observing daily minutiae of life that nobody bothered to look at before and asking questions that had previously been taken for granted? What is the common thread of all these different pieces?
At any rate, it might as well be, it certainly reads like a prototype of the Bill of Rights. I thought it was interesting that only a few of the rights (speech, liberty, property, whatever) addressed the inherent rights that men would demand from inside themselves, and the rest were about authority's relationship to the rights of men. I thought modernism had more to do with self-exploration than internal relationships. What occurred to me while I read the assigned packet, and especially Edmund Burke's piece and Wordsworth's poem, was that introspection and self exploration had erased a lot of the reverence and awed happiness that existed before. David Hume deciding that there was no reason for cause and effect must have been unfathomable to a bunch of British farmers used to worshipping their queen and fasting on Fridays.
But as far as the Declaration itself goes, it all sounds relatively fair, if not entirely applicable. It's an interesting juxtaposition to Rousseau, who's been busy making the case that society is responsible for the weakening and corrupting of man. Looking at the two, I assume that the writers of each felt they were right. So what I wonder is, is modernity the attempt to improve the quality of man's life? Is it simply when people started observing daily minutiae of life that nobody bothered to look at before and asking questions that had previously been taken for granted? What is the common thread of all these different pieces?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)