Wednesday, October 3, 2007

More on Werther

Over the past two classes, similar forms of the same complaint against the protagonists of Werther and Adolphe have come up: that these people are bad people because they're selfish and completely inconsiderate, to the point of being sociopaths, of anybody else.

Really, in both cases it has been because of disarmingly honest idea that each of them have had: Werther because he believes Lotte should belong to her because of how badly he wants her, and Adolphe because he doesn't seem to mind much when Ellenore kicks it. Both of these scream selfish because they value the self over a kind of general societal benevolence that says we should all be good and reasonably altruistic people.

But it seems to me that this kind of solipsistic selfishness is the natural conclusion of modernism. Look at Rousseau, his monad is the man who can take care of himself completely without outside help or society. Kant's Enlightenment means being able to fill societal roles while still maintaining an independence from them. Werther is a man who lives within himself, who emotes the way he wants to and meets people on his own terms. In fact, he finds it impossible to meet anyone else on their terms, and is subsequently ostracised from the high society he enters when he begins work with the diplomat.

All of these make the case that the independent self is the thing that is to be valued the highest, so why waste time dealing with the sorrows and woes of others. Why bother trying to keep societal order if you're trying to live free. Wouldn't anything else be counter-productive? I mean, freedom comes at the expense of obligatory behavior, which is why Rousseau's monad didn't do it, and it's why Werther and Adolphe don't. Whether or not you think it's a good thing, the fact is being completely free means not ever doing things you don't want to do, no matter how much social pressure there is on you to do them. Meaning, if you don't feel bad when your woman dies, then don't. And maybe that makes you a sociopath, but it makes you free as well. And isn't that what modernism is supposed to be about?

No comments: