Tuesday, November 27, 2007

Why I Hate Monsieur Grandet (and why I think Balzac did too)

Let's face it, this guy is one of the most awful characters ever conceived of in fiction. No Dickens villian could be as transparent or contemptible as Papa Grandet--the guy is pure evil, and if Balzac is saying that this is what people are like than I'm hitching to forested Sierra Leone to return to my roots with the savages.
The reasons for why this guy is so contemptible are obvious, but what stands out to me is the preface of the novel, in which grad school hero mentions several times that Balzac was capable of and did love his characters. Preliminary things I think should be pointed out: 1) the only flushed character is Grandet, I know next to nothing about Eugenie, 2) Balzac wasn't a writer, like so many of our modernist authors he was a guy, specifically a lawyer with some observations about the human condition that he wanted down on paper, 3) because he was a lawyer, the scenes in which fiscal law are discussed are painstakingly specific, and 4) this novel is indictment of human nature.
Interestingly, there are a lot of themes in Eugenie that only receive brief mention. There is the idea of religion, how it is dead in the hearts of men but how it really isn't, there are questions about Eugenie's life that don't get answered because Eugenie is not a strong enough character. The only thing that is painfully obvious is Grandet's unwholesome obsession with gold: he stares at gold for hours at a time! He's grasping for the Priest's crucifix! and the apparent observation that he isn't any different than anyone else, he's just more successful.
So I wonder if Balzac is saying that this is how people are, or about how rich people are, or if we can equate this obsession with money with an obsession of materialism, or some sort of God is Dead standpoint. But the overall message of the novel is quite depressing. I quote "How horrible is man's condition! He does not own one happiness whose source does not lie in ignorance of some kind." I'm reminded of the scene in which this quote occurs; Grandet's friends are over and it's apparent that nobody concerned has the slightest bit of affection for anyone else there. It's nauseating. And throughout the book we get Cruchot reminding Grandet of how close they are and Grandet doing the same to Cruchot, and I'm not inclined to believe either of them.
Again, Balzac was a lawyer, an observationist, not a writer, while the themes exist, they don't develop like they would in better novels. There isn't the inherent subtlety necessary to persuade me that Balzac was doing anything other than pointing out why people suck. Grandet doesn't redeem himself. I'm glad the bastard's dead. And I bet balzac is sort of glad he's dead.

No comments: